Overnight Cake Delivery to NYC

"Arrived on time. My friend loved it!"

"Wonderful cake. It's definitely rich with a beautiful chocolate flavor very moist and satisfying. "

"While I did not personally taste this cake, I sent it as a gift for my sister's birthday and she said it was amazing, moist and delicious and it arrived well packed and arrived timely. This is my second order from Bake Me a Wish, I had a slight issue with the first order but the customer service was amazing and went above and to correct it. Very pleased so far. "

"Great gift idea! The cake arrived on time, and was wonderful!"

"My daughter posted on Facebook looking for a chocolate or Oreo cheesecake recipe. She was going to make her own birthday cake because she doesnt live by family. This made me sad. I found a few websites that mail cheesecakes, but Bake Me a Wish had the best ratings & the best prices. She was so surprised. She loved the cake & was very impressed with the packaging! Ill definitely order again!"

"I sent this brownie cake to my son at University for his birthday with candles, and he loved it! He said it was delicious! Easy order, fast delivery. I will absolutely order again. "

"perfect gift! The birthday girl loved it!"

"Ive sent my 93 year old yesterday father the Viennese Coffee Cake several times and he absolutely loved it. When I went to send him it again for his birthday, it was only available for military bases. I was very upset about that! He called to thank me and I asked him if this new one was good or better. This new one was his favorite of the two! He said that I know the best gifts to buy him!"

"Very Tasty Birthday cake! A hit!"

"Delivery was good this time. Missing card and gift message. But he loves the cake!!!"

"Very fast service! Arrived overnight to California. Was a gift, son said it arrived in good condition and was delicious!"

"Absolutely Outstanding! Such a beautiful delicious surprise! Bake Me A Wish is the BEST! Customer Service is superb as well! Soldiers deserve a special treat too ..God Bless"

"Super excited still!!! Great option for birthdays for couples who share birthdays in the same month. I had this sent overnight and it arrived by 1030am!!! I will definitely order again very pleased with this experience. "

"Another wonderful cake from Bake Me A Wish! Decadent and delicious! It arrived in perfect condition and on-time."

"Wonderfully moist limoncello cake - ordered for my son's birthday and he loved it!"

"Fantastic! Beautiful! Punctual!! Wishes came true!"

"First time ordering a cake for someone and this has been great! My friend is allergic to gluten and I live in China so I had my fingers crossed. There were 4 cakes in there, didn't expect that so that was lovely! He also said and I quote Don't have the weird almost gritty aftertaste a lot of gluten-free products do.He loved it. 1010!"

"Beautiful and delicious "

"The recipient loved everything about this gift. From packaging to taste, she was very pleased. Thank you."

"My wife and I fought over who gets the last piece. Will order again.....great!"

"I was absolutely impressed with the service. The cake was delivered on time and not broken. My mom says it was delicious! With me being in Canada and my siblings in Jamaica, Thank you for helping us make our mom's birthday special! "

"Beautiful cake and tastes delicious! Ordered Thursday night and delivered as promised on Saturday! Fabulous dessert for Tax Party Sunday!!"

"Rich and decadent birthday gift that arrived exactly on time and in perfect condition! "

"Fabulous coffee cake with a light lemon flavor and delicious poppy seeds. My new favorite!"

"I ordered this cake 2 days before a birthday. It was delivered in a beautiful box, and was in perfect shape. It took 3 hours to come to room temperature I opted for this and tasted amazing!"

"The cake arrived on time and was amazing! The nuts and raisins were a tasty addition. The cake was moist and the cream cheese icing was perfect lite and creamy with only a bit of sweetness! I would highly recommend this carrot cake and would order this again. "

"This Lemon Coconut Cake is absolutely delicious!I highly recommend it!"

"This cake was absolutely delicious!"

"The yummiest and softest chocolate cake ever. "

"This cake was not only delicious but also super cute. It arrived on the date scheduled and was enjoyed by all. Thank you!"