Bake Me A Wish!™

contact us by email  1-888-YUR-WISH (987-9474)  monday - friday, 9 am to 5 pm

my account | event reminder | shopping cart

Celebrity Scavenger Hunt


This week our favorite wizard/actor celebrates his birthday on the 23rd of July. We are using this an excuse to launch another celebrity birthday scavenger hunt. Don’t worry, though, this one will be significantly easier. Simply answer one question a day by commenting on the blog! We will then choose a winner at random from all the entrants.

First off:

Q: If Harry Potter was a Bake Me A Wish cake, which flavor would he be?

60 Responses to “Celebrity Scavenger Hunt”

  1. Katie Says:

    I’ll say Peanut Butter Mousse because the gold of the peanut butter frosting matches the gold in Harry’s tie. And they love “chocolate frogs” in the wizarding world so I chose something with chocolate.

  2. Laurie Griffith Says:

    I’d have to say MAGIC BAR BROWNIE CAKE!
    No doubt!

  3. Anne M. Says:

    Triple Chocolate EnROBED Brownie Cake, ;)

  4. Steph Says:

    I have to agree that without a doubt he would be Magic Bar Brownie Cake. :)

  5. Birdie S. Says:

    Harry would be the Chocolate Truffle Lava Cake cause of the way he EXPLODES on the screen !!!

  6. Cali Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake!

  7. Elizabeth W Says:

    Vanilla Bean Cake….this way Bertie Botts Beans will be inspired by Harry and Bake Me A Wish to create a normal tasting flavor!

  8. Kristen Says:

    I would say Magic Bar Brownie Cake…Since He is Magic..*smile

  9. Elliott Says:

    My vote is for Magic bar brownie Cake. It is Harry Potter afterall.

  10. Jennifer Burks Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake!

  11. Pat McCray Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake is my choice – Harry performs magic for all then those chocolate like frogs for the Brownie part.

  12. Diane Says:

    Magic bar brownie Cake, Fits perfectly for Harry!

  13. Jennifer Woosley Says:

    I think he would be a Chocolate Truffle Lava Cake, He looks normal on the outside but when you get to know him you see just how special he is like the truffle lava in the Chocolate Truffle Lava Cake. mmmm

  14. jennifer giordano Says:

    Ya gotta go with Magic Bar Brownie Cake since he is all about the magic :)

  15. Chrisann Says:

    I’m another one that has to go with….
    Magic Bar Brownie Cake :)

  16. butterfly wishes and wonderland dreams Says:

    I have to go with the majority and say magic bar brownie cake since harry potter is all about magic.

  17. Sheryl Says:

    MAGIC Bar Brownie Cake, of course!

    Harry Potter IS Magic!

  18. Leslie S. Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake hands down would be the flavor.

  19. Lynn Says:

    I agree with everyone else! Magic Bar Brownie Cake all the way!

  20. Barbara C Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake. POOF, it would be gone like magic in my house! :)

  21. Laurie Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake sounds perfect for Harry Potter!!

  22. Jeannine m Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake because it is majoc of course lol

  23. Lauri Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake

  24. Shannon Schulte Says:

    Definitely the Magic Bar Brownie Cake for a magical experience of course! @sethandshannon1

  25. Beth Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake! because he’s magic. But Dan Radcliffe isn’t much of a cake person so hopefully Harry can handle it.

  26. C.J. Says:

    I’d say Magic Bar Brownie He could make it disappear in just one spell!

  27. Suzanne S Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake

  28. Janice Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake would be the obvious because of the “magic”, but Harry Potter’s more complex than that. There’s a lot more potential inside, and that’s exactly like the Chocolate Truffle Lava Cakes – it looks plain on the outside, but inside is bursting with delicious chocolate.

  29. Claudia M Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake with a twinkle :)

  30. Claudia M Says:

    follow on twitter @cdmtx65

  31. Julie Says:

    “Magic Bar Brownie Cake!” It even sounds like a spell Harry Potter would cast!

  32. noelle s Says:

    i’d say a chocolate truffle lava cake, cause inside its magic !!!!

  33. Becky J Says:

    I think Harry would be Chocolate Truffle Lave cake. All sweet and innocent on the outside with a lot of rage aka lava ready to ooze out on the inside!

  34. Gina Lannin Says:

    Red Velvet – he is the boy who lived, and this is the flavor that lived…

  35. Hannah B. Says:

    He’d be the Magic Bar Brownie Cake, of course! :)

  36. Lisa Grassetti Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake for sure :)

  37. Carrie Says:

    I too must go with the Magic Bar Cake

  38. linda dunphy Says:

    magic bar brownie cake… he is magic!!

  39. Donna B. Says:

    MAGIC Bar Brownie Cake – duh. LOL :)

  40. barbara wright Says:

    Triple Chocolate Enrobed Brownie, because they’re both very dark, delicious, and “enrobed” :-)

  41. rachael kyriakou Says:

    The Magic Bar Brownie cake :-)

  42. Tabathia B Says:

    Magic Bar brownie

  43. Meaghan F. Says:

    Although many people are saying the Magic Bar Brownie cake, I have to say that I don’t think that really fits him (except for the magic part of course). I believe that the Red Velvet Chocolate Cake would be perfect for Harry. He is very daring and courageous and not afraid at all to try new things. Also, it’s red and he is a Gryffindor, through and through. :)

  44. jengd Says:

    I can’t say Magic Bar Brownie Cake- it’s too obvious. I think he’d be Mississippi Mud Cake. While the stateside name is off, the principle is right- lots of things in the mix and the potential to get pretty messy.

  45. CrystalGB Says:

    He would be Magic Bar Brownie Cake. :)

  46. chris swan Says:

    I think Magic Bar Brownie Cake — perfect for him.

  47. DARLA KIDDER Says:

    Boston Cream Cake.

  48. catherine copeland Says:

    Honestly, would Harry eat anything other than Magic Bar Brownie Cake

  49. Stephanie V. Says:

    lava cake because he is still learning the tricks of magic but strong and brave on the outside
    tvollowitz at aol dot com

  50. Aisling Says:

    I think Harry would enjoy anything from Bake Me A Wish, just like we Muggles would. His favorite, though, would be the Magic Bar Brownie Cake.

  51. Christine Says:

    I think he would appreciate the Singular Sensation 4-pack so he could share with his friends.

  52. Allison Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie!

  53. nan lara Says:

    he would be a hogwarts carrot cake
    nannypanpan at

  54. Melodic Mom Says:

    Definitely the Magic Bar Brownie Cake. And if he was smart, he’d use his vanishing cloak to cover himself while eating it so he can have it all to himself. :)

  55. Kate Says:

    The Magic Bar Brownie Cake for sure!!

  56. Marilyn L Says:

    Magic Bar Brownie Cake

    jdmimi at gmail dot com

  57. Pamela S Says:

    The Magic Bar Brownie Cake of course!!

  58. Gianna Says:

    He would be a Magic Bar Brownie Cake.. I, on the other hand would be a Chocolate Mousse Tort cake ;)

  59. Auriette Says:

    I think Harry would like the Boston Cream Cake, because the chocolate outside and yellow inside reminds of what I’ve heard of Cauldron Cakes.

  60. Jane Says:

    Harry would be a Triple Chocolate Enrobed Brownie.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.