Baking Wishes Come True!

Bake Me A Wish!

From holidays and birthdays to business milestones, the perfect gift should always feel personal. We pride ourselves on crafting and delivering cakes, cookies, brownies, and more to help you celebrate the people who matter — whether that's family, friends, clients, or employees. Every item is made with premium ingredients and packaged with care, so it arrives looking and tasting as special as the occasion calls for. Whether you're sending one gift or a thousand, we make it simple to deliver something memorable right to their door.

Image of mixing cake batter
Image decorating cake
Image decorating cupcakes
2004
A Birthday Wish
Our founder had a simple wish: to send his mother a Tiramisu cake for her birthday. Having just moved to Manhattan, he was surprised to discover that no bakery in New York City would ship a cake by mail. Determined to find a solution, he got together with a few friends, and they decided to do it themselves — baking and shipping a beautiful cake right to her door. That moment of inspiration would change everything.
2005
BakeMeAWish.com Is Born
What started as a personal mission became a company dedicated to delivering divinely crafted birthday cakes to doorsteps across the United States. Partnering with award-winning New York City bakeries, Bake Me A Wish! set up a hassle-free gifting experience with customizable options at every turn — from personalized greeting cards to elegant gift packaging — making it effortless to celebrate someone special from anywhere in the country.
2007
Operation: Birthday Cake Is a Hit
Bake Me A Wish! has always believed that every American deserves a birthday cake — even those serving our country thousands of miles from home. Partnering with Soldiers' Angels, the company launched Operation: Birthday Cake and has since donated tens of thousands of birthday cakes to deployed military personnel overseas and veterans here at home. The program quickly became one of the company's proudest traditions.
2012
Not Just Cake Anymore!
How about some cookies to go with that cake? Bake Me A Wish! expanded beyond its award-winning cake selection to introduce delicious gourmet cookies and brownies, bringing some of the finest flavors available anywhere on the web. The company also began developing curated gifts for the holiday season, laying the groundwork for a year-round gifting destination.
2015
Pies, Cheesecakes, and Cupcakes, Oh My!
Bake Me A Wish! continued to grow its offering with gourmet pies perfect for Thanksgiving tables, rich and creamy cheesecakes, and outstanding gourmet cupcakes in both mini and JUMBO sizes. New gift baskets, bakery towers, and innovative packaging rounded out the company's expanding year-round and holiday lineup — giving customers even more ways to make any occasion unforgettable.
2018
B2B Gifting Explodes
Years of effort and product development paid off as the company's business gifts division made a serious impact. Thanksgiving pies and innovative bakery gift assortments positioned Bake Me A Wish! as a noted provider of premium corporate gifts for employee appreciation, client recognition, and holiday gifting. The company was also tapped by 1-800-Flowers to help fill out its bakery gifts category — a milestone partnership that validated the brand on a national stage.
2020
Delivering Through Covid
When the world slowed down, Bake Me A Wish! kept going. As one of the few gifting companies that continued delivering throughout the pandemic — and without a price increase — we made sure birthdays and milestones could still be celebrated, whether in person or remotely. For many customers, a cake at the door became a meaningful connection during one of the most difficult periods in recent memory.
2021
Inc. 5000 Recognition
Bake Me A Wish! earned national recognition for its resilience and growth, landing on the prestigious Inc. 5000 list of America's fastest-growing private companies — ranking number 248 regionally. The company also received honors from Newsweek, further cementing its reputation as an innovative leader in the gourmet gifting space.
2025
20 Years of Smiles Delivered
Two decades in, and the mission remains the same: make every occasion sweeter. Customers have fallen in love with our sumptuous recipes, personalized greeting cards, and elegant packaging. From our original birthday cakes, we've grown to offer a magnificent lineup of mouthwatering treats — cookies, brownies, cupcakes, cheesecakes, pies, and quiches — plus gorgeous snack and fruit baskets. Today, Bake Me A Wish! is the go-to source for premium bakery gifts, and we're just getting started. Here's to the next 20 years of helping you celebrate and strengthen your most important relationships.

Our Promise

Quality Gift Delivery with an On-Time Guarantee

🎂

Award-Winning Bakeries

We partner with the finest New York bakeries to bring you gourmet treats crafted with premium ingredients.

📦

Elegant Packaging

Every order arrives beautifully presented with a personalized greeting card, ready to delight.

🚚

Nationwide Next-Day

Fresh-baked and delivered to doorsteps across the United States with next-day delivery available.

💜

We Give Back

5% of every order goes to BMAW Cares, our goodwill program making contributions where they matter most.

Testimonials

As Seen On National Media

For over 20 years, Bake Me A Wish! has received national media attention for its excellent service and good will — featured on Fox & Friends, Dr. Phil, Oprah Daily, The Sun, and many more.

View Our Press Features →
Jeannie - Your Personal Wishbot
Jeannie
Thanks for stopping by Bake Me A Wish! I'm Jeannie. How can I help?
0/500