Can you describe this Gift?
Our Key Lime Pie delivers the perfect balance of tangy citrus and sweet, creamy indulgence in every bite. This classic Southern dessert features a velvety key lime custard nestled in a buttery graham cracker crust, topped with billowy, golden-brown meringue that's as beautiful as it is delicious.
Handcrafted with real key lime juice, this refreshing gourmet pie captures the essence of sunshine and celebration. The bright, zesty flavor paired with the smooth custard filling creates a memorable dessert experience that stands out from ordinary sweets.
Send this Key Lime Pie as a thoughtful gift for birthdays, thank you gestures, or just because moments. Delivered fresh to their door in elegant bakery packaging with a personalized greeting card, it's a gift-ready treat that shows you care:perfect for celebrating from anywhere.
What are the Gift Details?
Serving Size: Serves 6-8
Size: 8-inch diameter
Kosher: Certified Kosher Dairy
Shipping: Available for nationwide delivery
Storage Instructions
For Optimal Freshness:
- Best consumed immediately upon delivery
- Refrigerated storage: Up to 5 days in an airtight container
- Frozen storage: Up to 2 months when properly sealed
Allergen Information
Contains: Milk, wheat, soy, and eggs
Cross-Contamination Warning: This product is manufactured on shared equipment that also processes tree nuts including peanuts, almonds, hazelnuts, pecans, and walnuts.
Important Note: Our production facility is not certified gluten-free.
For complete allergen details, please refer to the product label or contact our customer service team.
How do you ship a Key Lime Pie?
To secure overnight service, gift orders must be placed by 4:30PM ET. We’ve worked with our delivery partner to provide the best available rate for your gift. Morning and Saturday deliveries are available and we can also ship to Alaska and Hawaii for an additional charge.
Every order will be confirmed via the email provided for your account. Along with confirmation, you will receive a verification that your order has shipped as well as confirmation that your order has arrived. Please put bakemeawish.com on your safe sender list so that you do not miss these important messages.
Our gifts are perishable and on-time delivery is of utmost importance! As such, we cannot be held responsible for incorrect or incomplete addresses. Apartment numbers and suites for residential and business deliveries, as well as business names, must be included. Please ensure you have the full address - delays due to missing or wrong information will nullify guaranteed delivery. We want your gift to arrive fresh and delicious!
Orders placed after 4:40PM EST Monday through Friday will be processed the following business day. Deliveries to Alaska & Hawaii are an additional $25.00; no international shipments. Our gifts are perishable and on-time delivery is of utmost importance! We cannot be held responsible for incorrect/incomplete addresses. Apartment numbers and suites for residential and business deliveries must be included. Please ensure you have the full address - delays due to missing or wrong information nullifies guaranteed delivery. We want your gift to arrive fresh and delicious!
FAQ
Why am I not able to select certain dates for delivery on your delivery date calendar?
How do I dispose of the packaging and coolants?
At what time will my gift be delivered?
What if I forgot to add a discount code?
What do other Customers say?
You and your recipients mean the world to us.
Keylime pie shipped on time, receiver said it looked great, hasnt eaten it at the time this review is being submitted.
PAMELA E.
SCARSDALE, NY
June 29, 2026, 11:07 am
Thoughtfully packaged. Beautiful presentation.Very small in size.
PATRICIA W.
PINSON, AL
May 4, 2026, 9:22 am
Best key lime pie ever!
JOAN N.
HAMBURG, NY
April 8, 2026, 10:40 am
I sent this as a gift and my recipient went wild with delight! Key Lime is an all time favorite
SUSAN C.
BUFFALO, NY
March 19, 2026, 9:46 am
Always a hit. Key-Lime Pie is my Godmother's favorite. I have sent from other vendors, but the reliability of delivery and the quality at Bake me a wish makes it the best option.
JEFFREY W.
NEWPORT, NC
September 19, 2025, 9:18 am
Sent Key Lime Pie as a gift. Recipients loved it said it was delicious. Easy to order. Delivered on requested date. Will order again!
GREG M.
LANTANA, TX
January 25, 2024, 7:58 am
delivered on time product very good
DAVID L.
MEBANE, NC
October 28, 2023, 10:22 am
I ordered this for my dads 70th birthday and the first thing he said was that the presentation was exquisite! He later said the pie was delicious and went so far as to go on your website to check out the company! Thanks for making his birthday so special!
LISA F.
CONCORD, NC
October 20, 2023, 1:01 pm
I ordered this pie for my daughters birthday. It was delivered to her apartment at college on a Saturday. The delivery was quick, easy, and earlier than I expected! The look on my daughters face as she FaceTimed me opening her gift at college, far away from me was so precious. . She stated it is the best Keylime pie she ever tasted!Thank you for a wonderful experience!
JULIE W.
NEW CUMBERLAND, PA
September 15, 2023, 6:19 am
Gift was received on her birthday and the key lime was delicious.
ROBIN M.
MIDDLETOWN, CT
August 20, 2023, 8:56 pm
My dad loved his Birthday key lime pie! Arrived on time, nice presentation and said it tasted very good!
MELANIE L.
WATERTOWN, CT
August 20, 2023, 11:34 am
My son loved his birthday pie! It was a huge hit, thank you.I am grateful to the employees that fixed my mistake on shipping address so that the pie arrived on time. Will definitely order again!
KATHLEEN K.
WALPOLE, MA
August 19, 2023, 3:46 pm
I sent this as a gift to my Aunt for her birthday. She called to thank me for the Lemon cheesecake. She really liked it but was surprised when I told her it was Key Lime pie.
TERESA W.
NORTH PORT, FL
August 13, 2023, 11:25 am
Great flavor- not too bitter, loved the cream and crust!
AMBER B.
GRANDVIEW, TX
August 4, 2023, 1:58 pm
Amazingly delicious and they were able to deliver this from NYC all the way to Albuquerque for my mans birthday.Thank you for helping me now make two of my favorite people feel special!!
KIMBERLY M.
MIDDLETOWN, RI
July 10, 2023, 6:54 am
I ordered the key lime pie for my friend, and she loved it! Arrived on time and delicious.
MAYBELLE A.
TULLAHOMA, TN
June 28, 2023, 10:17 am
Very good, arrived on time and undamaged
William M.
SPRINGFIELD, VA
June 21, 2023, 1:28 pm
excellent pie, light and delicious. they also have excellent customer service !!
ATHENA D.
LAKEWOOD, NJ
May 13, 2023, 10:03 pm
Wonderful service, enjoyed the delicious pie, delivered timely and kept up with the tracking so we knew it got delivered. Thank you.
SUSAN H.
MORGAN HILL, CA
April 1, 2023, 5:30 pm
My father loved his pie for his 86th birthday.
WILLIAM B.
TUPELO, MS
November 18, 2022, 10:08 am
Arrived on time. My daughter said it was delicious and for me to definitely order again!
SONJA J.
MARION, VA
September 10, 2022, 11:09 am
As the sender, I really like the way it's packaged and kept cold, even if the recipient isn't present for delivery. The packaging and presentation of the pie and the letter are at a level of quality that I'm happy to deliver to people I care about! And from those who ate it, they said it's tastefully balanced not too sweet or sour and held its texture, even with the box outside for a few hours!
HYLTON M.
FAIRFIELD, CA
August 16, 2022, 12:17 am
What I love about this company is that delivery is always prompt! Key Lime pie is my sons favorite so ordered One to be sent to him for his birthday since I could not be there with him. He liked the pie but was a little disappointing as there was hardly any crust. Would still order again from this company.
Joan L.
DAVIE , FL
July 22, 2022, 11:29 am
From what I understand, the pie is delicious. However, it was delivered almost on it's side, so it was a little bit of a mess when opened.
BLAIR S.
CARY, NC
July 14, 2022, 10:04 am
