We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
1-888-987-9474
9AM - 6PM EST Monday - Friday
Have Questions? See our FAQs sectionOr use our Contact Us form
Cookies and Cream Cheesecake
52.00
"A bit expensive but very convenient to send for loved ones. "
Gluten-Free Chocolate Truffle Lava Cakes
50.00
"Excellent cake and delivered on time"
Coconut Cream Cake
54.00
"Ordered this for my sisters birthday. She thought the cake was delicious, and thoroughly enjoyed the cake!"
Triple Chocolate Enrobed Brownie Cake
48.00
"Sent this to my daughter for her birthday. She loved it."
Gluten-Free Vanilla Cake
60.00
"Happy that you could provide buttercream icing. Product was excellent. Delivery was on time and with care by UPS."
Blackout Cake
"Sent this to my dad for his 80th birthday. He said it was the best tasting cake hed ever had. Loved it."
Black and White Mousse Cake
"Looked beautiful and tasted even better!"
Classic Confetti Cake
"excellent gift! recipient enjoyed it!"
Gluten-Free Red Velvet Cake
"Fantastic! Beautiful! Punctual!! Wishes came true!"
Boston Cream Cake
53.00
"My dad loves eclairs so I knew this was the cake for him. He loved it!"
Chocolate Mousse Torte Cake
"I HAD A SPECIAL BIRTHDAY CAKE I GOT FOR MY SON HE JUST LOVED IT, AND WAS SO HAPPY I GAVE HIM SUCH A SPECIAL BIRTHDAY CAKE."
Flourless Chocolate Cake
58.00
"Flourless chocolate cake is superb. I sent it to my cousin and she states its the best cake ever . Its rich and moist!! "
Chocolate Truffle Cake
55.00
"The recipient was very pleased with the cake and the speed at which it was delivered across the country. The cake was still chilled when received. I didn't see a lot of options for writing i.e. Happy Birthday on various cakes but not sure if I missed where that option may have been available. Will definitely look closer next time. And yes there will be a next time!"
Red Velvet Chocolate Cake
"I ordered the cake for my husbands birthday and he loved the cake . I was so happy , wasnt sure about the cake but from now on I would definitely order from Bake me a wish. Thank you so much "
Tiramisu Classico Cake
"Sent this cake to my friend, she said she really liked it. I'm hoping it made her feel better somehow from all the stuff she is going through. Will buy from this company again, because it was a pleasant experience and they sell good quality products."
Cookies and Cream Brownie Cake
"Arrived in perfect condition and tasted great!"
Classic Cake Sampler
"Cakes arrived on time. I was kept informed of delivery status. Receipient indicate the cakes were good. Just wish UPS still rang the doorbell because these sat outside for a day."
Golden Fudge Southern-Style Cake
56.00
Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake
"The cake was delicious! It was also delivered on time and packed safely. I will definitely use bakemeawish again in the future."
Lemon Coconut Cake
"I sent this cake to my father for his 87th birthday -- it was a big hit. "
Gluten-Free Double Chocolate Cake
"Awesome gift for gluten intolerant person They loved the cake and it made their day!"
Lemon Poppy Coffee Cake
31.50$45.00SALE!
"Fabulous coffee cake with a light lemon flavor and delicious poppy seeds. My new favorite!"
Caramel Apple Cake
45.00
"Wonderful. I and my sister have been sending your cakes to each other ever since we lost our husbands. Now I added my daughter in law. The food is always great, always on time. Always a nice surprise. "
German Chocolate Cake
"Daughter's birthday cake surprise. She loved it. Had a piece at midnight before her big day. Went to the office, came home and her BF had eaten what was left. Impulse control issues I think. Arrived on time intact. Next year include a locking box. "
Rainbow Cake
"It was tasty and fresh!"
The Freedom Cake
84.00
"Delicious! And couldnt be more happy than to have a chance to send a cake to a military member!"
Blossoming Rose Cake
"The cake was delivered as expected. It was beautiful and delicious! I was so lucky as I only ordered it 24 hours in advance-perfect last-minute gift! Thank you!!!!"
Tres Leches Cake
"Very pleased with timely delivery. Enjoyed the texture, flavor as well as presented in delivery box.In overall it was delicious."
Strawberry Funfetti Cake
"Yummy cake. Recommend this."
Carrot Cake
"A delicious and fabulous cake!"
Chocolate Chip Coffee Cake
Cinnamon Coffee Cake
"Perfect for those busy mornings during this holiday season. Moist and delicious!! Shipping rate is a bit high, however it was delivered promptly and safely."
Vanilla Bean Cake
"Fabulous Birthday gift we love to send our employees!"
Limoncello Cake
"Gift was received and recipient was amazed at how well packaged,and of course the most important how perfectly delicious it is, and will most definitely use your company for sending a special gift to friends. Thanks for the excellent service. "