We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
1-888-987-9474
9AM - 6PM EST Monday - Friday
Have Questions? See our FAQs sectionOr use our Contact Us form
Carrot Cake
54.00
"Beautiful and excellent cake. Delivered on time. Have ordered before and everything is delicious"
Cinnamon Coffee Cake
45.00
"This is the most amazing, delicious Coffee Cake I could recommend. It is absolutely perfect."
Red Velvet Chocolate Cake
52.00
"Karen said cake smelled delicious and tasted great"
Gluten-Free Vanilla Cake
60.00
"Good looking and tasted great"
Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake
53.00
"I treated myself to this cake on my birthday and I was not disappointed. It was moist and deliciousa perfect way to celebrate!"
Blossoming Rose Cake
55.00
"Such a beautiful gift. We sent this to an employee for a work anniversary gift. She said it was almost too pretty to eat . . . but she and her family did and LOVED it. Thanks"
Black and White Mousse Cake
"Oh so yummy! Moist and flavorful! "
Blackout Cake
"I ordered this for my adult sons birthday, as he lives across the country now. I usually order one from small bakeries around his area, but thought Id try something different this time and see how it went. It arrived packaged well and on time for him to enjoy on his birthday. He said it was an excellent cake, and he is quite picky when it comes to any food not made at home. Definitely recommend!"
Tiramisu Classico Cake
"Perfect gift for everyone! Moist, delicious, pretty packaging. Bakemeawish.com is wonderful all the way around "
Cookies and Cream Cheesecake
"Absolutely delicious.! Delivered on schedule. "
Triple Chocolate Enrobed Brownie Cake
48.00
"Would like to congratulate & thank the crew & staff of Bake me a wish , for outstanding performance! My first born been away for a while working in the air force. I found this site Wed. trying to figure out how can I make his birthday extra special. I order Wed his b-day Sat. & put delivery date Fri. It didn't disappoint me, it was delivered perfectly on time & great condition! So happy mom!"
Golden Fudge Southern-Style Cake
56.00
Cookies and Cream Brownie Cake
"Extremely delicious. Not too sweet."
Lemon Poppy Coffee Cake
"Fabulous coffee cake with a light lemon flavor and delicious poppy seeds. My new favorite!"
Caramel Apple Cake
"Sent this 3000 miles! Arrived in perfect condition and was told that it was really really good! "
Chocolate Chip Coffee Cake
Chocolate Truffle Cake
"I sent this a birthday gift and was very pleased with the care taken to package and deliver on time. "
Boston Cream Cake
"Arrived on time in perfect condition, and tastes great!! He loved it "
Classic Confetti Cake
"Perfect birthday cake. Loved it"
Classic Cake Sampler
"These samplers are amazing. The carrot cake was so good. It wasnt too sweet and just right. The other 3 are just as fabulous. Moist and just perfect. We are lifetime customers. How have I lived in NY my whole life and never knew about Bake Me A Wish?! "
Vanilla Bean Cake
"Cake was awesome, came well packaged and was a beautiful birthday surprise"
Strawberry Funfetti Cake
"The young lady loved it and said it was delicious. On time, too! Thank you."
Flourless Chocolate Cake
58.00
"Flourless chocolate cake is superb. I sent it to my cousin and she states its the best cake ever . Its rich and moist!! "
Chocolate Mousse Torte Cake
"This is our favorite cake ever. We buy this every single year for my husbands birthday. We dont even slice it, we just all dig in with our forks. So hard to stop eating. Soooo good! And it feels great supporting a good cause too. "
Lemon Coconut Cake
"Delicious. Moist. Not too sweet. Arrived on the exact date in perfect condition. "
Rainbow Cake
"Great product! delivered perfectly "
Limoncello Cake
"Its delicious. A big hit with everyone. You wont be disappointed. "
Coconut Cream Cake
"Cake was delivered quickly. Packaging was perfect. A bit smaller than I expected, but delicious. Perfect for my husband's birthday!"
Gluten-Free Double Chocolate Cake
"My daughter reported that this cake was spectacular!Thank You for providing me with an opportunity to participate in her 'special birthday'!"
Tres Leches Cake
"Cake was delivered on time. The intended recipient didnt even get a chance to taste it, but everyone else at party did and was gone, so apparently it was a hit! "
Gluten-Free Red Velvet Cake
"Packaged well to beat the heat of a july delivery."
The Freedom Cake
84.00
"Absolutely Outstanding! Such a beautiful delicious surprise! Bake Me A Wish is the BEST! Customer Service is superb as well! Soldiers deserve a special treat too ..God Bless"
German Chocolate Cake
"My daughter and granddaughter and I sent for my son in laws birthday, he said it was the best German Chocolate cake he's had! So helpful on next day delivery! "
Gluten-Free Chocolate Truffle Lava Cakes
50.00
"Delightful. A perfect dessert if youre looking for a gluten free treat. "