We use the finest ingredients. If you have any questions or concerns regarding a specific ingredient in any of our products (for allergies, etc.), please check with us directly at 888-987-9474 before placing an order. Our gifts include ingredient and nutritional information enclosed with the package.

Yes. All our gifts include a greeting card reflecting the occasion of your gift. 250 characters of well-wishing can be entered on the card.

Cardboard Box: We recommend breaking down the white Bake Me A Wish box and disposing of it in the appropriate cardboard recycling area. Gel Packs: The best way to dispose of the gel ice packs is to allow them to fully thaw. Next, cut open the side and empty the gel into your waste receptacle. Recycle the empty plastic pouch with other plastics. We highly recommend that you do not put the thawed gel down your sink or septic tank. While it is nontoxic and non-hazardous, it can further clog the pipes if there is a pre-existing clog. The method above is the best method of disposal. Dry Ice: The dry ice will arrive in a plastic bag inside of the cooler. If you receive the gift and there is an empty bag with no dry ice; than the dry ice did its intended job. The dry ice will slowly evaporate releasing the cold to keep your gift safe and secure from the heat. Please dispose of the plastic bag into your garbage. If you receive your gift with ruminates of dry ice, we recommend removing the dry ice bag from the cooler, removing your gift and then returning the bag to the empty cooler leaving it at room temperature in a well-ventilated area until evaporated. Please note, do not touch dry ice with bare skin. Dry ice may burn skin if not protected. Additionally, DO NOT dispose of the dry ice in your sink as it may cause damage to your plumbing. Coolers: What’s cool about our coolers? We use recycled Styrofoam that is environmentally conscious. Yes! Contrary to popular belief, Styrofoam can be recycled! Bake Me A Wish only uses recycled foam for its coolers and encourages its recipients to help keep the cycle going. For a complete list of locations that allow drop off of polystyrene material for recycling, please visit: https://www.foamfacts.com/recycling/ If your area does not recycle Styrofoam, please reuse our coolers. Keep it handy in the trunk of your car for heat sensitive groceries. Pack a lunch for a family outing. Keep snacks and drinks cool for random road trips!

We recommend removing the gift from the cooler as soon as possible to rest at room temperature for up to one hour before enjoying. You can leave the shrinkwrap on the gift until you serve. Our gifts stay good in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days, or in the freezer for up to 2 months. All care instructions are listed on the cake labels Refrigerated cakes (layer cakes, cheesecakes): good for 5 days refrigerated Brownie / coffee cakes/4-inch cakes: good for 5 days, non-refrigerated and covered Frozen: all cakes can be frozen for 2 months. Cookies / brownies: eat within 5 days. Do not freeze, do not refrigerate.