✕
Mouth-Watering Savings!
Enjoy 15% off your next order
plus hear about our newest gourmet creations, special offers, and moreWe won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
This gift is available for overnight and 2-day delivery and is guaranteed to arrive on-time via UPS. To secure overnight service, gift orders must be placed by 4:30PM ET. We’ve worked with our delivery partner to provide the best available rate for your gift. Morning and Saturday deliveries are available and we can also ship to Alaska and Hawaii for an additional charge.
Every order will be confirmed via the email provided for your account. Along with confirmation, you will receive a verification that your order has shipped as well as confirmation that your order has arrived. Please put bakemeawish.com on your safe sender list so that you do not miss these important messages.
Our gifts are perishable and on-time delivery is of utmost importance! As such, we cannot be held responsible for incorrect or incomplete addresses. Apartment numbers and suites for residential and business deliveries, as well as business names, must be included. Please ensure you have the full address - delays due to missing or wrong information will nullify guaranteed delivery. We want your gift to arrive fresh and delicious!
This product is certified kosher dairy by OK Kosher. In fact, we have the largest selection of Kosher Dairy baked goods anywhere online! For more info, see Kosher Certification info page Opens a new window .
Gifting Rewards is a special customer program which allows our members to earn rewards and perks. You earn 1 Wish Point for ever $1.00 spent. For more info, see Gifting Rewards info page Opens a new window .
On-time delivery is of utmost importance to us and our delivery service provider, UPS. Your gift is guaranteed to be delivered on time or your shipping is free!
Part of our mission is giving back to the world we share. That's why 5% of every order is dedicated to BMAW CaresOpens a new window, a goodwill program that makes contributions where they matter most.
Got this as a gift and they absolutely loved it! Fast shipping as always and it was delicious!
2023-11-17 23:31:28
They were so happy to get this cake! It tasted so good. Arrived very nicely delivered.
2023-11-12 00:07:33
My son loved it... it was a nice surprise for him since he loves peanut butter cups! Delivery was perfect and amazingly quick! Thank you!
2023-10-21 10:40:26
Arrived on time, sooner than I expected and the recipient loved the cake!
2023-10-17 02:00:47
I never got to see anything but the outer box and my nephew decided to put it in the freezer for Thanksgiving upcoming versus the birthday. What I was especially impressed with is that on Oregon Thyme about 130, I was still able to order a next day delivery and you guys mustve been hustling to the post office, but it arrive just like promised, and well packaged. I plan to use you again!
2023-10-16 14:05:56
Packaging was excellent. We all loved this cheesecake, it was very delicious.
2023-09-15 11:21:32
Was well received and delicious.
2023-09-15 10:23:04
It's really good cheesecake but needs a little more peanut butter flavor!
2023-09-12 13:23:05
This was a gift for a friend. Got rave reviews. Im going to order one for my family for the holidays.
2023-09-08 16:58:41
Sent to my daughter for her birthday. She loved it. Very delicious
2023-09-08 12:20:09
Really delicious and my gift recipient loved it! Bake Me a Wish is always so consistent and perfect!
2023-09-06 20:39:48
I was thinking all was going great when this came early and all, but I do think that just maybe the dry ice bag should have been sealed. Just so no harmful fumes might not have been released. I have ordered items that needed dry ice in the package and the ice bag was sealed before.
2023-08-21 10:13:21
Rich, delicious and utterly delightful!
2023-08-17 12:39:46
The peanut butter cheesecake was awesome!Delivered promptly and packaged very well!
2023-08-16 09:54:04
Absolutely excellent!!!!
2023-08-05 19:01:34
Sent this as a gift and everyone loved it! This is the second cheesecake I have sent and the previous one was just as wonderful.
2023-07-27 20:15:41
Absolutely delicious! Shipped the very next day arriving in time to celebrate a birthday!
2023-07-15 10:51:18
Very decadent and delicious! Arrived in perfect condition and was enjoyed by all of the family! We would definitely order this cheesecake again!
2023-07-14 14:15:13
Awesome! Beautiful and delicious. Delivered right on time and made my son very happy for his birthday!
2023-07-14 13:30:09
My friend loved the cake, she said service was premium for delivery and the taste was outstanding! I will definitely will order again!
2023-07-10 10:36:57
My son n law & daughter enjoyed their Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake & he doesnt of gourmet cookies. They love their anniversary treat. Thank you Bake Me A Wish for making their wedding anniversary treat special and delicious! And unique!
2023-07-03 08:25:30
I purchased this for my husbands Birthday. He said the cheesecake texture was smooth and light, his preference, 5 stars. I rate its appearance, 3 stars. Possibly during shipping the box was not handled properly? The majority of the PB cups and morsels were toppled to one side of the cake. I added a few roses to the other side to make it look more presentable.
2023-06-25 08:16:43
They loved it.
2023-06-24 12:53:05
Everyone loved it and said it was high end.
2023-06-23 20:29:29
Delicious cake. Everyone enjoyed it
2023-06-22 13:46:08
This was for a birthday gift. It arrived on time, was in great shape and tasted fantastic. I will be ordering again.
2023-06-20 08:59:30
The cheesecake tasted amazing. I rated it a 45 because I think it is small for the price.
2023-06-18 17:33:57
Item arrived exactly when scheduled, it was packed very well and was still cold. We sent this as a Father's Day gift, and Dad loved it.
2023-06-18 11:38:44
We sent this as a gift for Father's Day and they absolutely loved it! Taste was great and super fresh !
2023-06-18 11:12:31
This was awesome I loved every piece of it!
2023-05-06 10:27:54
A delicious cheesecake. It was an excellent choice for my son for his birthday
2023-05-03 11:10:59
Cake was delicious, but when it arrived the entire top of it was smashed in and all the reeses were on one side, so i was a little disappointed.
2023-05-01 10:01:41
My aunt loved this gift. Said packaged nice & matching card. The toppings were piled on 1 side due to shipping. Maybe wrap the top for more secure shipping. Important thing is she said was delicious. And it did get delivered on chosen date. I would send again to other friends or family.
2023-04-11 17:18:45
I sent this cake and assortment of brownies to my son for his 26th birthday. He lives in Fort Lauderdale and it was the first time he was so far away from home for his birthday. BakeMeAWish did a GREAT job. The cakebrownies arrived on time and packaged beautifully. He loved it all and said it all tasted great. I will be ordering again! Thank you for doing a GREAT job!!
2023-04-06 18:06:19
Sent this to my daughter for her 37th birthday. She absolutely loved it. Everyone she shared a piece with just raved about the taste. She wants it every year now for her birthday! Im going to order one for my own birthday!! The packaging and presentation of the cheesecake is top notch.
2023-04-04 23:51:53
Ordered this for our anniversary and my fiance loves it!
2023-03-18 21:13:35
Delivered on time and my boyfriend and his family loved it. Will surely order again soon!
2023-03-06 14:45:34
Highly recommended!
2023-02-05 09:18:21
I didnt get to eat it since I sent it to my brother hundreds of miles away. But he LOVED IT! And delivery was smooth and on-time.
2023-01-30 10:36:56
The cake arrived on time for birthday celebration. It was delicious. We would order this again!
2023-01-14 21:36:04
Fabulous cake thank you
2023-01-01 09:36:21
It was really good!
2023-01-01 08:44:51
Best cheesecake ever!
2022-12-22 14:34:56
Super delicious! Amazing service! thank u
2022-12-21 08:57:43
Always love your cheese cakes.
2022-12-12 23:26:27
Great cake! Arrived on time and everyone enjoyed it!
2022-12-02 18:08:03
My friend was completely amazed! Thank you!
2022-11-29 08:34:16
Sent for a birthday. I am told it is fantastic! Will have to get one for myself!
2022-11-29 08:10:51
My sister and her family loved it!
2022-10-30 10:21:47
Really good, I sent it to my brother and it was perfect
2022-10-22 11:26:22
Fabulous! -tastes as good as it looks!
2022-10-13 14:51:59
Everything was terrific -- on time delivery beautifully packaged birthday recipient who is a peanut butter addict loved it! Great value.
2022-09-25 20:58:15
My son loves this cheesecake. He says it tastes creamy and so good. He loves this gift!
2022-09-24 09:58:23
Delicious treat! I ordered for my niece in Ohio and she is still raving about how great it tasted. She is a vet picky cheesecake eater. Shipping and delivery were breeze and it arrived still cold
2022-09-10 11:29:51
Everyone at the party wanted to know where I got the cheesecake from. It was delicious. Thanks to Bake Me a Wish!
2022-09-05 10:26:23
Everyone raved about how delicious this cake was!!
2022-09-01 17:20:20
Loved it! Super!
2022-08-08 06:22:04
Arrived on time and beautiful. The cake is rich, creamy and delicious. It was for my sons birthday. He and everyone else enjoyed every last bite. I highly recommend this decadent cheesecake.
2022-07-24 15:27:41
Can't go wrong with peanut butter AND cheesecake!
2022-06-27 07:39:31
The cheesecake arrived fresh and in decent condition. I thought it was a decent tasting cheesecake. All toppings were on one side of cake like it had been stored on side. Probably shipping issue not company issue. I may order again for my brother's birthday in November
2022-06-19 22:00:04
This is a great company to order baked goods. I sent my father a cheesecake and brownies combo for father's day and it was a big hit. I will definitely use them again.
2022-06-19 12:10:41
I loved the easy ordering process and ability to have the exact message I wanted sent on my card. But more importantly, the cake was boxed beautifully, arrived when promised and was hand delivered personally to my daughter. As she is 4,348 miles away from here, I wanted to be sure it reached her in time. She loved it and said the cheesecaske was fantastic and not too rich. Perfect!
2022-06-13 08:41:18
Arrived right on time and in great condition. She loved it and said it was heavenly! to quote the recipient.
2022-06-03 14:31:11
My daughter enjoyed the cake! She was a little disappointed that most of the topping had shifted to one side and it was just a plain cheesecke and no flavor of peanut butter.
2022-05-14 11:09:58
Have been a customer of Bake Me A Wish for quite some time and the quality has been the same since.Every product is great, always.
2022-04-25 10:40:23
Im always happy with my products and deliveries with bake me a wish. I have all my birthday surprises delivered by bake me a wish and my family and friends are always delighted with their cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, or pies. This peanut butter cheesecake was amazing and my son got it for his 35th birthday and said it was delicious!
2022-04-25 10:24:36
Beautiful Cake and delicious!!!!
2022-04-23 09:57:16
Got this for my daughter in university for the second year in a row. This is her favorite. I get it shipped to FL, It arrived on her birthday as scheduled and in good condition. She says it's delicious!
2022-04-06 11:20:00
Delicious!!
2022-03-27 10:21:42
This is a great-tasting cake! Cant give 5 stars due to the way it arrived-lets just say the cake was not aesthetically pleasing.
2022-03-18 10:46:48
Arrived in a soggy state. Tasted OK
2022-03-06 13:08:34
Delivery was on time even though it was snowing.My son absolutely love the peanut butter cheesecake. It was delicious. Will definitely use again.
2022-02-27 10:07:32
Sent this to my daughter on her birthday. She and her friends loved it!! Delicious and decadent cheesecake and it arrived on time! I will definitely order from Bake Me a Wish again
2022-02-27 09:36:47
Ive been sending this cake to my best friend for her birthday for 3 years now, and she absolutely loves it!
2022-02-17 10:23:29
My son loved receiving this cheesecake. He said it tasted great! Shipping was on time and delivered in great condition.
2022-02-11 17:18:11
Ordered as a gift and the feedback I received was Oh my gosh, that cake is so good! Am also happy to report that it arrived right on time as scheduled. Will definitely be ordering from you again.
2022-01-30 12:23:28
Its a good cheesecake!
2022-01-02 21:28:13
My boyfriend loves the peanut butter so thats why I asked for that but I didnt expected that It would was as good as it was everyone even who are not lovers of peanut butter Love it
2021-09-25 21:30:08
I sent this to my daughter for her birthday. She loves peanut butter cups and this cheesecake definitely did not disappoint!!! She said it was just amazing!!! It was packaged perfectly and delivered on the morning of her birthday which is the date requested. Couldn't be happier! Thank you for great service and a delicious cake!!!
2021-07-28 10:16:55
YUMMY! Could have used a bit more peanut butter taste, but everyone raved about it.
2019-12-29 22:11:25
You are a great team to business with! My son was very pleased with the order and said it was the BEST cake he ever had! Thank you for making my son Happy on our special day! Blessings to all of you!! Claire H,Fl.
2019-09-10 07:58:20
Excellent Cheesecake per my son and his friend. Sent to them to enjoy for their 1st Valentine's Day and they both went crazy for your cheesecake! Thanks so much, now I need to order it for my hubby! My son is a cheesecake hound and he said it was one of the Best he has ever had and he Loved the peanut butter flavors!
2019-02-19 15:24:53
Delicious cake tasted as expected and looked just like on the picture!
2018-09-07 18:28:07
or call 1-888-987-9474
We’re here for you 8AM - 5PM Eastern Monday - Friday
Have Questions? See our FAQs section
By entering your email, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Please read our Privacy statement for more information.