Can you describe this Gift?
Our Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake turns the classic candy favorite into a show-stopping dessert that chocolate and peanut butter lovers dream about. This indulgent cheesecake begins with a rich chocolate cake base, layered with velvety chocolate cheesecake and our signature creamy New York-style cheesecake.
Crowned with glossy chocolate fudge frosting and generously topped with peanut butter chips, chocolate chunks, and whole peanut butter cups, every slice delivers that perfect sweet-and-salty combination. It's handcrafted to bring bakery-fresh quality right to your celebration.
Send this decadent cheesecake to celebrate birthdays, say thank you, or make any occasion unforgettable. Delivered gift-ready with a personalized greeting card in an elegant gift box, it's the perfect way to show someone you care:especially when you can't be there in person.
What are the Gift Details?
Serving Size: 6-8 servings
Size: 7-inch diameter
Kosher: OK Certified
Shipping: Available for nationwide delivery
Storage Instructions
For Optimal Freshness:
- Best consumed immediately upon delivery
- Refrigerated storage: Up to 5 days in an airtight container
- Frozen storage: Up to 2 months when properly sealed
Allergen Information
Contains: Milk, wheat, soy, and eggs
Cross-Contamination Warning: This product is manufactured on shared equipment that also processes tree nuts including peanuts, almonds, hazelnuts, pecans, and walnuts.
Important Note: Our production facility is not certified gluten-free.
For complete allergen details, please refer to the product label or contact our customer service team.
How do you ship a Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake?
This gift is available for overnight and 2-day delivery and is guaranteed to arrive on-time via UPS. To secure overnight service, gift orders must be placed by 4:30PM ET. We’ve worked with our delivery partner to provide the best available rate for your gift. Morning and Saturday deliveries are available and we can also ship to Alaska and Hawaii for an additional charge.
Every order will be confirmed via the email provided for your account. Along with confirmation, you will receive a verification that your order has shipped as well as confirmation that your order has arrived. Please put bakemeawish.com on your safe sender list so that you do not miss these important messages.
Our gifts are perishable and on-time delivery is of utmost importance! As such, we cannot be held responsible for incorrect or incomplete addresses. Apartment numbers and suites for residential and business deliveries, as well as business names, must be included. Please ensure you have the full address - delays due to missing or wrong information will nullify guaranteed delivery. We want your gift to arrive fresh and delicious!
Orders placed after 4:40PM EST Monday through Friday will be processed the following business day. Deliveries to Alaska & Hawaii are an additional $25.00; no international shipments. Our gifts are perishable and on-time delivery is of utmost importance! We cannot be held responsible for incorrect/incomplete addresses. Apartment numbers and suites for residential and business deliveries must be included. Please ensure you have the full address - delays due to missing or wrong information nullifies guaranteed delivery. We want your gift to arrive fresh and delicious!
CUSTOMER FAVORITES
Be the hit of the party! Would you like to see more gifts?
IS THIS GIFT KOSHER?
This gift is certified kosher dairy by OK Kosher. In fact, we have the largest selection of Kosher Dairy baked goods anywhere online! For more info, see Kosher Certification info page Opens a new window .
WILL I EARN REWARDS?
Gifting Rewards is a special customer program which allows our members to earn rewards and perks. You earn 1 Wish Point for ever $1.00 spent. For more info, see Gifting Rewards info page Opens a new window .
IS THIS GUARANTEED ON TIME?
On-time delivery is of utmost importance to us and our delivery service provider, UPS. Your gift is guaranteed to be delivered on time or your shipping is free!
WHY SHOP BAKE ME A WISH?
Part of our mission is giving back to the world we share. That's why 5% of every order is dedicated to BMAW CaresOpens a new window, a goodwill program that makes contributions where they matter most, including our Operation: Birthday Cake program.
Description
Our Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake turns the classic candy favorite into a show-stopping dessert that chocolate and peanut butter lovers dream about. This indulgent cheesecake begins with a rich chocolate cake base, layered with velvety chocolate cheesecake and our signature creamy New York-style cheesecake.
Crowned with glossy chocolate fudge frosting and generously topped with peanut butter chips, chocolate chunks, and whole peanut butter cups, every slice delivers that perfect sweet-and-salty combination. It's handcrafted to bring bakery-fresh quality right to your celebration.
Send this decadent cheesecake to celebrate birthdays, say thank you, or make any occasion unforgettable. Delivered gift-ready with a personalized greeting card in an elegant gift box, it's the perfect way to show someone you care:especially when you can't be there in person.
Details
Serving Size: 6-8 servings
Size: 7-inch diameter
Kosher: OK Certified
Shipping: Available for nationwide delivery
Storage Instructions
For Optimal Freshness:
- Best consumed immediately upon delivery
- Refrigerated storage: Up to 5 days in an airtight container
- Frozen storage: Up to 2 months when properly sealed
Allergen Information
Contains: Milk, wheat, soy, and eggs
Cross-Contamination Warning: This product is manufactured on shared equipment that also processes tree nuts including peanuts, almonds, hazelnuts, pecans, and walnuts.
Important Note: Our production facility is not certified gluten-free.
For complete allergen details, please refer to the product label or contact our customer service team.
Shipping
- 2-Day Shipping W-F: $15.99
- Overnight Shipping: $22.99
- 2-day Saturday Delivery, available for most areas: $27.99
- Overnight Saturday Delivery, available for most areas: $27.99
Orders placed after 4:30PM EST Monday through Friday will be processed the following business day. Deliveries to Alaska & Hawaii are an additional $25.00; no international shipments. Our gifts are perishable and on-time delivery is of utmost importance! We cannot be held responsible for incorrect/incomplete addresses. Apartment numbers and suites for residential and business deliveries must be included. Please ensure you have the full address - delays due to missing or wrong information nullifies guaranteed delivery. We want your gift to arrive fresh and delicious!
FAQ
What happens if I provide the wrong address or an address with missing information?
If you discover after your order has shipped that there is a problem with the address, we do have options.
UPS Change of Address: UPS offers a service to intercept a package that is already in transit and change or update the shipping address. There is a charge of $18 and it typically will cause a one business day delay in delivery. You must contact our Customer Care team at 888-987-9474 and provide payment details before we can make the adjustment to the address of a package in transit. Once a change of address has been made with UPS and additional transit time is imposed on our perishable gifts, we no longer guarantee the freshness of our gifts.
IMPORTANT! Bake Me A Wish! cannot be held responsible for incorrect or omitted information. Any exception received, due to missing or bad information, immediately nullifies guaranteed delivery. Apartment numbers and suites for residential and business deliveries must be included for on-time delivery. Your cake will not be delivered on time without this information! UPS Will Call: UPS offers a service to hold your package at the nearest UPS customer center for pickup. There is no charge for this service. If you request the will call on the same day delivery is due, the local UPS driver will take your package to the customer center after their route is complete. We are unable to tell you a specific time the package will be available for pick up. You must contact the local UPS customer center. We will provide you with the address and phone number of the location. A government issued photo ID is required when shipping or picking up a package at a UPS Customer Center and must match the name of the receiver on the shipping label. Please note: UPS Will Call option not offered for all locations due to UPS restrictions
What is your guarantee for fresh, on-time delivery?
How do I dispose of the packaging and coolants?
Do you offer free shipping promotions?
What do other Customers say?
You and your recipients mean the world to us.
Peanut butter cup pieces taste weird but everything else was great. The peanut butter cups tasted like medicine or something odd
ADRIENNE N.
LAS VEGAS, NV
June 12, 2026, 1:27 pm
Peanut Butter Cheesecake was amazing! Shipping was good too!
JOLINE M.
WAUSEON, OH
June 12, 2026, 1:25 pm
Thoughtfully packaged. Beautiful presentation. Very small in size.
PATRICIA W.
PINSON, AL
May 4, 2026, 9:23 am
The cake arrived perfectly on time. Very happy with how it turned out. The recipient was very excited to have it for her birthday cake and the flavor was wonderful. Thank you for making a delightful cheesecake.
JEFFREY D H.
HORACE, ND
May 4, 2026, 9:15 am
Very well packed, it got very much on time, and was safely delivered. The taste is phenomenal! Thank you for such great service, guys! Looking forward to my next purchase!
NORMANDE C.
TLAXCALA, TLAXCALA
April 8, 2026, 10:41 am
The cake was delivered on time! My friends said it was absolutely delicious .
MARTHA G.
WAKE FOREST, NC
March 30, 2026, 9:05 am
Ariived on time, packed well. My brother loved it!
Doris S.
ALEXANDRIA, VA
March 23, 2026, 9:42 am
My brother loved this cheesecake. He loves Reese cups and he said this one had really big pieces of it on the cheesecake. It was delivered on time and appreciate the updates..
MARYANN T.
HIGH SPRINGS, FL
September 7, 2025, 8:37 pm
Great tasting products. Easy to order and ship. A little bit pricey but really convenient.
SCOTT F.
AURORA, IL
August 23, 2025, 9:18 am
Incredibly decadent. The chocolate compliments the cheesecake in a fantastic way!
JEANNE S.
PASADENA, MD
June 22, 2025, 4:21 pm
It was fabulous and arrived on time
FARHEEN I.
KARACHI, SINDH
June 9, 2025, 1:47 pm
My family loved this cheesecake!! It was delicious and delivered on time for my brothers birthday! He said it was the perfect gift!
M DORINE N.
CLAYTON, NC
June 1, 2025, 10:23 am
Cake arrived on time for birthday and it was so delicious. I am a huge peanut butter and cheesecake fan. My two favorite things combined with each other, and every bite was so good. I will order more cakes from here in the future.
VERSHA D.
SHELBYVILLE, IN
May 9, 2025, 7:52 pm
Bought this for My Husband at Christmas time, and he absolutely loves it. He says all of these cakes have been absolutely the best hes ever had and I have ordered seven different ones.
MISTY D.
ALCOA, TN
February 24, 2025, 11:38 am
This was sent as a last minute birthday gift and I couldnt have been happier with the purchase. The recipient LOVED it. I will definitely order again for distant friends. Thank you so much!
CHRISTINA U.
CASCADE, VA
February 2, 2025, 10:43 am
A wonderful shopping experience, convenient and professional! Delivered on time with a careful packaging and beautiful personalized card, the cheesecake tasted fresh and delicious, my friend loved it so much
SELINA L.
NEWYORK, NY
January 26, 2025, 10:18 am
This is my sons favorite cake from Bake Me a Wish. I sent it to him for the second consecutive year. It looks so good Im going to have to buy myself one!
M SUZANNE L.
LARKSPUR, CO
January 15, 2025, 11:44 pm
This cheesecake was so creamy and well worth the extra money I spent vs going to a local Publix. I am so glad I went this route. My husband said it was the best cheesecake he has had and thought coming from New York made it even more special!
ELIZABETH L.
GRAHAM, NC
January 6, 2025, 10:08 am
Delicious, fully loaded and fresh. Good quality and portion. Was a nice, decadent birthday surprise.
JOHANNAH J.
HOLLAND, NY
November 11, 2024, 11:38 am
Delicious dessert for my peanut butter lovin sons birthday!
MARY W.
OAKTON, VA
October 29, 2024, 8:33 am
It was fantastic and came on time. I would definitely use you again!
TIFAINE L.
BURNSVILLE, MN
October 11, 2024, 10:09 am
I ordered peanut butter cheesecake, for my husband birthday, he really love it.
MILEEN S.
SINGAPORE, SD
October 10, 2024, 11:26 am
My client realllly loved this one! She said it was the right amount of sweetness! Thanks so much
MJ M.
LAPU-LAPU, CEBU
September 20, 2024, 5:26 am
Its small but decadent! Wonderful birthday gift for my father.
JACQUELYN F.
PUNTA GORDA, FL
August 23, 2024, 11:13 am
